Previous Play

5. Be Authentic and Transparent

Next Play

7. Cultivate Support Networks

6. Practice Culturally
Appropriate Mentoring

Culturally appropriate mentoring affirms identity and lived experience. It connects young adults with mentors who respect their background, understand community context, and practice cultural humility and approach relationships with openness and a willingness to learn from others’ experiences. The aim is not to “fix” a young person—it’s to develop a reciprocal relationship that opens doors, shares networks and opportunities, and strengthens belonging.

Workforce-development guides for OY explicitly call out the value of mentoring and connections as part of workforce development support. An analysis done by the Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring found that mentoring has been shown to improve outcomes for participants in youth and young adult programs.

Jump to: Takeaways

Who is this play for?

image of 2 team members. should have a comic book effect and afrofuturism graphics effect

Organizational Leaders

Direct-Support Staff

image of an office worker. should have a

image of what a youth organization staff member who is a person of color and has a comic b

Young Adult Employers

Why this
matters:

Belonging accelerates trust.

Representation and respect lower barriers to engagement.

Navigation improves.

Culturally aware mentors help understand systems and expectations.

Context reduces missteps.

Mentors grounded in local reality give better-fitted advice.

Communities benefit.

Local mentoring weaves tighter networks of support.

Isolation

decreases.

A steady relationship buffers stress and disconnection.

What makes good mentorship?

Humility

The most critical thing is for mentors to recognize that their mentee is THE expert on their own life—listening first, staying curious, and being willing to learn and adjust rather than “fix” or lecture. It builds trust because it communicates respect, reduces judgment, and makes it safer for Opportunity Youth to share what’s really going on so mentors can support goals that they define.

Building connections through lived experience

Whenever possible, it's helpful to recruit mentors with similar backgrounds as your participants. This is one reason peer mentoring can be so powerful. This is especially the case when participants are dealing with major challenges like being justice-involved or having to be a caregiver.

Building quality relationships through trust

Even though they don’t spend as much time with participants as staff members, mentors still need to be committed to developing meaningful connections. That means taking time to get to know their mentees as people.

Consistency and
follow-through

They need to be there in predictable and positive ways for the folks they are mentoring. If they say they are going to do something they need to do it.

Put it into action

Start with a simple mentoring model to pilot and define what “mentoring” means for your program

There are many proven forms of mentoring for OY. Three of the most common are:

1:1 career mentor (often employer/alumni)
Near-peer mentor (recent grads/young professionals)
Group mentoring (one mentor + small cohort)

Think about which one would be best for your program to try. Then define the mentor’s job in 1–2 sentences (e.g., career exploration + social-emotional support + navigation coaching). Also write out the expected amount of time mentors will be asked to give and when those interactions will happen.

Finally, think about what, if any training and support those mentors will need. Make sure you are not expecting mentors to take on work that should be done by staff members (like case management).

Recruit mentors who reflect participant communities—and set clear standards

Go where your mentors already are: alumni, neighborhood businesses, faith communities, and professional associations of color. Pitch a specific, time-bounded role (e.g., “two hours every other week for 4 months”) and emphasize support and training. Clarity on commitment helps mentors opt in realistically and follow through.

Document standards for screening, onboarding, boundaries, and communication so consistency doesn’t depend on a single staff member. Use MENTOR National’s Elements of Effective Practice as your backbone; then layer in your cultural context: https://www.mentoring.org/resource/elements-of-effective-practice-for-mentoring/.

Provide your mentors with materials about working with OY

Great intent isn’t enough; mentors need shared language and tools. Some topics to consider include active listening, cultural humility, boundaries, and practical career support (workplace norms, networking, job search).

Much of what we have in this playbook can be used as a resource for mentors. Specialized training has been linked with stronger mentoring relationships in program studies. There are also resources on the web available through places like mentoring.org and at the Center for Evidence-Based Mentoring.

Be sure to create a schedule for regularly checking in with them and making sure they feel supported in mentoring

Structure mentoring to fit real life

Offer multiple formats—1:1, group mentoring, and near-peer models—so participants can choose what feels right. Provide a flexible meet-up menu (on-site, virtual, phone) with a recommended cadence (e.g., biweekly) and simple agendas (check-in, goal, next step).

Clarity helps pairs spend time connecting rather than negotiating logistics.

Set realistic goals for the first month (e.g., build rapport, identify one concrete target, agree on communication norms). Resources from Big Brothers Big Sisters can help you scaffold meetings, expectations, and safety practices: https://www.bbbs.org/.

Coach and support mentors over time.

Even experienced mentors need a backstop. Schedule brief “mentor office hours,” share quick tip sheets, and host quarterly sessions to swap strategies. Ask mentors to log simple notes (attendance, topics, next steps) so staff can spot patterns early and offer help.

This is especially important at the start of a program. Best practices recommend checking in with mentors at least twice during the first month and then at least monthly after that.

Provide a clear escalation path for tough moments—missed meetings, boundary concerns, or crises—so mentors never feel alone. The National Mentoring Resource Center’s practice guides and training are practical and free: https://nationalmentoringresourcecenter.org/.

Celebrate culture—and evaluate together.

Weave culture into activities: local history walks, neighborhood business tours, storytelling nights, or arts collaborations. Invite mentors and mentees to co-plan at least one culturally rooted activity each cycle; shared pride strengthens bonds and community connection.

Close each cycle with a short evaluation conversation and an anonymous check-in. Ask, “What helped you feel seen?” “What got in the way?” and “What should we change next time?” Use that feedback to refine recruitment, training, and matching.

Takeaways:

Structured mentoring can improve the outcomes of programs.
It’s important for mentoring to be based in humility, curiosity, and, when possible, shared lived-experience.
It’s important to be clear from the beginning about your expectations for mentors.
Good mentorship programs provide coaching and support for mentors.
There are many resources available across the web to help with incorporating mentoring into program offerings.

What's next